Checking for newer data...
Newer data is available for this fighter.
Aimee Hanson
Inactive 29m
Weapons & Rank/ratings
Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword
Current
1076
#4,263
Peak
1096
April 2026
Record
13W · 42L · 3D
Last
May 2026
Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre
Current
975
#2,280
Peak
975
May 2026
Record
2W · 11L · 1D
Last
May 2026
Mixed & Men's Steel Rapier and Dagger
Regional
Current
850
#1,291
Peak
850
May 2026
Record
7W · 23L · 3D
Last
May 2026
Underrepresented Genders & Women's Steel Longsword
Current
1121
#562
Peak
1122
April 2026
Record
13W · 42L · 3D
Last
April 2026
Mixed & Men's Singlestick
Current
1086
#304
Peak
1087
April 2026
Record
9W · 15L
Last
April 2026
Women's Steel Longsword
Regional
Current
1080
#360
Peak
1087
August 2025
Record
13W · 42L · 3D
Last
August 2025
Mixed & Men's Steel Single Rapier
Current
1135
#1,047
Peak
1170
May 2024
Record
7W · 23L · 3D
Last
May 2025
Mixed & Men's Steel Sword and Buckler
Regional
Current
928
#1,283
Peak
936
May 2025
Record
1W · 7L
Last
May 2025
Women's Steel Rapier and Dagger
Inactive
Current
1157
Peak
1174
March 2024
Record
7W · 23L · 3D
Last
March 2024
Underrepresented Genders and Women's Steel Rapier and Dagger
Inactive
Current
1157
Peak
1174
March 2024
Record
7W · 23L · 3D
Last
March 2024
Women's Singlestick
Inactive
Current
882
Peak
896
March 2024
Record
9W · 15L
Last
March 2024
Underrepresented Genders & Women's Singlestick
Inactive
Current
882
Peak
896
March 2024
Record
9W · 15L
Last
March 2024
Scout analysis
Longsword
17W · 49L · 3D (25%)
Longsword
17W · 49L · 3D (25%)
Form
Steady
Recent 29% vs older 21%
▾
Form
Steady
Recent 29% vs older 21%
Record: 17W · 49L · 3D (25%)
Recent half (34 fights): 29%
Older half (34 fights): 21%
Delta: +8%
Current streak: 7 Losses
Based on 69 recorded longsword fights.
Schedule
Punching up
-2.3 vs expectation
▾
Schedule
Punching up
-2.3 vs expectation
Quality wins (won as clear underdog): 2
Over/under vs expectation:
-2.3
(8 actual / 10.3 expected, n=34)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Knockout killer
Pool 19% · Elim 43%
▾
Stage
Knockout killer
Pool 19% · Elim 43%
Pool stage: 10W · 42L (19%)
Elimination: 3W · 4L (43%)
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 1121
Peak rating: 1122 (April 2026)
Gap to peak: -0
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
By division
Mixed Steel Longsword
6W · 24L · 3D
(18%)
-1.5 vs expectation
(n=24)
avg opponent 1358
Women's Steel Longsword
8W · 14L
(36%)
Mixed Steel Longsword (Tier B)
1W · 7L
(13%)
-1.1 vs expectation
(n=6)
avg opponent 1225
+6 fights in 1 thinner division
Rapier
7W · 23L · 3D (21%)
Rapier
7W · 23L · 3D (21%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 13% vs older 31%
▾
Form
Cooling
Recent 13% vs older 31%
Record: 7W · 23L · 3D (21%)
Recent half (16 fights): 13%
Older half (16 fights): 31%
Delta: -18%
Current streak: 2 Losses
Based on 33 recorded rapier fights.
Schedule
Comfort bracket
-2.3 vs expectation
▾
Schedule
Comfort bracket
-2.3 vs expectation
Over/under vs expectation:
-2.3
(0 actual / 2.3 expected, n=6)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 25%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 25%
Pool stage: 7W · 21L (25%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 1157
Peak rating: 1174 (March 2024)
Gap to peak: -16
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
By division
Mixed Steel Single Rapier
5W · 10L · 3D
(28%)
-2.3 vs expectation
(n=6)
avg opponent 1343
Mixed Steel Rapier And Any Sidearm
2W · 9L
(18%)
+4 fights in 1 thinner division
Singlestick
10W · 19L (34%)
Singlestick
10W · 19L (34%)
Form
Rising
Recent 43% vs older 21%
▾
Form
Rising
Recent 43% vs older 21%
Record: 10W · 19L (34%)
Recent half (14 fights): 43%
Older half (14 fights): 21%
Delta: +22%
Current streak: 2 Wins
Based on 29 recorded singlestick fights.
Schedule
Comfort bracket
+0.7 vs expectation
▾
Schedule
Comfort bracket
+0.7 vs expectation
Over/under vs expectation:
+0.7
(4 actual / 3.3 expected, n=8)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Fast starter
3 exchange-coded matches
▾
Style
Fast starter
3 exchange-coded matches
Exchanges per point: 3.67
Avg exchanges / match: 7.3
Doubles / match: 1.67
First scorer rate: 100%
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 35%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 35%
Pool stage: 9W · 17L (35%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 1086
Peak rating: 1087 (April 2026)
Gap to peak: -0
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
By division
Mixed Singlestick
8W · 11L
(42%)
+0.7 vs expectation
(n=8)
avg opponent 1051
Women's Singlestick
2W · 8L
(20%)
Rapier & Dagger
9W · 14L · 1D (38%)
Rapier & Dagger
9W · 14L · 1D (38%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 25% vs older 50%
▾
Form
Cooling
Recent 25% vs older 50%
Record: 9W · 14L · 1D (38%)
Recent half (12 fights): 25%
Older half (12 fights): 50%
Delta: -25%
Current streak: 1 Loss
Based on 24 recorded rapier & dagger fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Knockout killer
Pool 29% · Elim 50%
▾
Stage
Knockout killer
Pool 29% · Elim 50%
Pool stage: 5W · 12L (29%)
Elimination: 2W · 2L (50%)
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
▾
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
By division
Women's Steel Rapier & Dagger
8W · 8L
(50%)
Mixed Steel Rapier & Dagger
1W · 6L · 1D
(13%)
avg opponent 899
Sabre
2W · 11L · 1D (14%)
Sabre
2W · 11L · 1D (14%)
Form
Rising
Recent 29% vs older 0%
▾
Form
Rising
Recent 29% vs older 0%
Record: 2W · 11L · 1D (14%)
Recent half (7 fights): 29%
Older half (7 fights): 0%
Delta: +29%
Current streak: 1 Win
Based on 14 recorded sabre fights.
Schedule
Punching up
+0.2 vs expectation
▾
Schedule
Punching up
+0.2 vs expectation
Quality wins (won as clear underdog): 1
Over/under vs expectation:
+0.2
(2 actual / 1.8 expected, n=6)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 15%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 15%
Pool stage: 2W · 11L (15%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 975
Peak rating: 975 (May 2026)
Gap to peak: +0
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
Messer
0W · 8L · 1D (0%)
Messer
0W · 8L · 1D (0%)
Form
Steady
Recent 0% vs older 0%
▾
Form
Steady
Recent 0% vs older 0%
Record: 0W · 8L · 1D (0%)
Recent half (4 fights): 0%
Older half (4 fights): 0%
Delta: 0%
Current streak: 8 Losses
Based on 9 recorded messer fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 0%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 0%
Pool stage: 0W · 7L (0%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
▾
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
Sword & Buckler
1W · 7L (13%)
Sword & Buckler
1W · 7L (13%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 0% vs older 25%
▾
Form
Cooling
Recent 0% vs older 25%
Record: 1W · 7L (13%)
Recent half (4 fights): 0%
Older half (4 fights): 25%
Delta: -25%
Current streak: 7 Losses
Based on 8 recorded sword & buckler fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 13%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 13%
Pool stage: 1W · 7L (13%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 928
Peak rating: 936 (May 2025)
Gap to peak: -8
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
Mixed Weapon
2W · 6L (25%)
Mixed Weapon
2W · 6L (25%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 0% vs older 50%
▾
Form
Cooling
Recent 0% vs older 50%
Record: 2W · 6L (25%)
Recent half (4 fights): 0%
Older half (4 fights): 50%
Delta: -50%
Current streak: 4 Losses
Based on 8 recorded mixed weapon fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 33%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 33%
Pool stage: 2W · 4L (33%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
▾
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
By division
+8 fights in 2 thinner divisions
Smallsword
2W · 6L (25%)
Smallsword
2W · 6L (25%)
Form
Steady
Recent 25% vs older 25%
▾
Form
Steady
Recent 25% vs older 25%
Record: 2W · 6L (25%)
Recent half (4 fights): 25%
Older half (4 fights): 25%
Delta: 0%
Current streak: 2 Losses
Based on 8 recorded smallsword fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's
exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate,
comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 33%
▾
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 33%
Pool stage: 2W · 4L (33%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
▾
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak is relative to an isolated regional scene - see the "How to read this profile" note below.
Reach
8 events · us · 2.2 yrs active
5 rated weapons
▾
Reach
8 events · us · 2.2 yrs active
5 rated weapons
Tournaments: 8
Countries fought in: 1 (us)
Months active: 26
Fights / year: 93.2
Rated weapons: 5
Clubmates
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
(73)
- Sam Brian●
- Christopher Preyer●
- Jakob Seehaas●
- Bryan Howard●
- Michael Stack●
- Ryan Collins●
- Colin Knipp●
- Jessica Young●
- Alisha Saulnier●
- Kyle Wingo●
- Joseph Martinez●
- Jacob Lockhart●
- Jami Davies●
- Coleby Grammer●
- Travis Price●
- Cody Rasmussen●
- Jacob White●
- Michael Walz●
- Roy Murray●
- Alexander Rodriguez●
- Skylar Hoch●
- Jay Johnson●
- Quinlon Eisenhaur●
- Beth Culp●
- Marlin Muza●
- Elijah Shafer●
- Scott Boland●
- Audrey Plunkett●
- Wyatt Meriwether●
- Landon Tuso●
- Lisa McGuire●
- Henry van der Laan●
- Moses Sanderson●
- Brogan Cooper●
- Skye Winter●
- Christopher Mitchell●
- Mads Arnautov●
- Stephen Wuensche●
- Weston Price●
- Addison Hernandez●
- Eric Westerfield●
- Max Cooper●
- Steven Lawrence●
- Christopher Carlson●
- Justin Burks●
- Kaleb Bermond●
- Richard Cook●
- Parker Collins●
- Rebecca Seelinger●
- Baer Kenney●
- Joel Norieega●
- Alex Meier●
- Robert Ault●
- August Eichman●
- Horus Clark●
- Toby Cosner●
- Emmett Pellant●
- Marcus Guerrero●
- Mathyis Hoover-Holthus●
- Noah Long●
- Cole Ivey●
- Joel Hahn●
- Nicholas Weber●
- Roger Ivey●
- Chad Summa●
- Phil King●
- Morgan Spring-Glace●
- Robert Earl Barnhill●
- Harper Spring-Glace●
- Luke Minton●
- Zin Khant●
- Wren Ryan●
- Matthew Vindoska●
Events & fights
(8)
SwordStrong 2026●
May 2026 · us
31 fights
▾
May 2026 · us
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 4305 ▼244 · 1,076.9
- Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 2290 ▲448 · 975.3
- Mixed & Men's Steel Rapier and Dagger Rank 1291 · 850.5
WIN
1268 31%
LOSS
1147 40%
LOSS
LOSS
LOSS
899
LOSS
Lake Hall●
·
Heartland HEMA Historical Fencing Club●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-4
Review →
LOSS
899
LOSS
1537 13%
25 fights
▾
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 4064 ▲271 · 1,096.9
- Mixed & Men's Singlestick Rank 283 ▲84 · 1,087.9
- Underrepresented Genders & Women's Steel Longsword Rank 561 ▲22 · 1,122.7
Donnybrook 2025●
August 2025 · us
28 fights
▾
August 2025 · us
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 3906 ▲164 · 1,071.6
- Women's Steel Longsword Rank 317 ▲78 · 1,087.4
- Mixed & Men's Singlestick Rank 391 ▲44 · 951.2
- Underrepresented Genders & Women's Steel Longsword Rank 502 ▲125 · 1,087.4
LOSS
Jakob Seehaas●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Mixed Weapon
· Pools
Score 7-10
Review →
SwordStrong 2025●
May 2025 · us
31 fights
▾
May 2025 · us
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 3919 ▲52 · 1,049.0
- Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 2103 · 868.2
- Mixed & Men's Steel Single Rapier Rank 863 ▼83 · 1,146.8
- Mixed & Men's Steel Sword and Buckler Rank 1161 · 936.7
LOSS
1752 5%
LOSS
1294
LOSS
1323 39%
WIN
983
LOSS
Donnybrook 2024●
August 2024 · us
21 fights
▾
August 2024 · us
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 3252 ▲170 · 1,029.3
- Mixed & Men's Singlestick Rank 262 ▲38 · 915.9
WIN
558 74%
LOSS
Green Chapel 2024●
June 2024 · us
8 fights
▾
June 2024 · us
Rating outcome
- Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 3363 ▲61 · 988.4
- Mixed & Men's Singlestick Rank 294 · 688.2
LOSS
1563 12%
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Pool Set 1
Score 2-4
Review →
1328 24%
LOSS
LOSS
825
SwordStrong KC 2024●
May 2024 · us
18 fights
▾
May 2024 · us
Bend the Knee 2024●
March 2024 · us
40 fights
▾
March 2024 · us
Rating outcome
- Women's Steel Longsword Rank 254 · 988.2
- Underrepresented Genders & Women's Steel Longsword Rank 386 · 988.2
- Women's Steel Rapier and Dagger Rank 18 · 1,174.8
- Underrepresented Genders and Women's Steel Rapier and Dagger Rank 28 · 1,174.8
- Women's Singlestick Rank 9 · 896.5
- Underrepresented Genders & Women's Singlestick Rank 9 · 896.5
WIN
Alisha Saulnier●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Bronze Medal Match
Score 6-9
Review →
LOSS
Alisha Saulnier●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Pool Set 1
Score 6-9
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Semifinals
Score 3-7
Review →
WIN
Alisha Saulnier●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Bronze Medal Match
Score 6-9
Review →
LOSS
Alisha Saulnier●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Pool Set 1
Score 6-9
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Longsword
· Semifinals
Score 3-7
Review →
WIN
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Bronze Medal Match
Score 2-3
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
WIN
Emily Carol Smith●
·
Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-2
Review →
LOSS
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 2-3
Review →
WIN
Emily Carol Smith●
·
Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy●
Rapier & Dagger
· Quarterfinals
Score 3-2
Review →
WIN
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Bronze Medal Match
Score 2-3
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
WIN
Emily Carol Smith●
·
Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-2
Review →
LOSS
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Rapier & Dagger
· Pool Set 1
Score 2-3
Review →
WIN
Emily Carol Smith●
·
Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy●
Rapier & Dagger
· Quarterfinals
Score 3-2
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Singlestick
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
LOSS
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Singlestick
· Pool Set 1
Score 2-3
Review →
LOSS
Jessica Young●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Singlestick
· Pool Set 1
Score 3-7
Review →
LOSS
Jami Davies●
·
Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts●
Singlestick
· Pool Set 1
Score 2-3
Review →
How to read this profile
Rating is Glicko-2: the number shown is score - 2*RD (97.5% confidence lower bound), not raw skill. Inactive fighters "drift down" as RD grows - not because they got worse.
Hemaratings ratings don't factor in match scores, exchange counts, or doubles. Scout's score-margin and style metrics describe HOW a fighter fights, not the rating tier their results earned.
Hemaratings recomputes in batches days-to-weeks after events. A fighter's most recent tournament may not yet be reflected.
Regional At least one of this fighter's ratings is "island" - their rank/percentile is relative to an isolated regional scene, not the global population. Cross-scene rating comparisons are unreliable.