Skip to main content

Robert Smith Logan

Battlefield KdF● · United States
Inactive 13m
View HEMA Ratings Profile Report an issue with this data

Weapons & Rank/ratings
Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword
Current
974 #5,289
Peak
1182 June 2016
Record
28W · 90L · 4D
Last
August 2025
Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre
Inactive
Current
788
Peak
807 July 2023
Record
0W · 4L
Last
July 2023

Scout analysis

Longsword

28W · 89L · 4D (23%)
Form
Steady
Recent 23% vs older 23%
▾
Record: 28W · 89L · 4D (23%)
Recent half (60 fights): 23%
Older half (60 fights): 23%
Delta: 0%
Current streak: 3 Losses
Based on 121 recorded longsword fights.
Schedule
Punching up
-12 vs expectation
▾
Quality wins (won as clear underdog): 3
Upset losses (lost as clear favourite): 2
Over/under vs expectation: -12 (15 actual / 27 expected, n=92)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Fast starter
7 exchange-coded matches
▾
Exchanges per point: 2.36
Avg exchanges / match: 3.7
Doubles / match: 0.43
First scorer rate: 86%
Dominant wins (shut-out): 50%
Comeback wins (was behind): 50%
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 27%
▾
Pool stage: 12W · 32L (27%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
208 pts off peak
Currently below peak
▾
Current rating: 974
Peak rating: 1182 (June 2016)
Gap to peak: -208
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.
By division
Mixed Steel Longsword 26W · 81L · 4D (23%) -11.1 vs expectation (n=84) avg opponent 1277
+10 fights in 2 thinner divisions

Sabre

0W · 4L (0%)
Form
Building
0% win rate · 4 fights
▾
Record: 0W · 4L (0%)
Trajectory needs 8+ fights - will sharpen as more data lands.
Current streak: 4 Losses
Based on 4 recorded sabre fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
▾
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
▾
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate, comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 0%
▾
Pool stage: 0W · 4L (0%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
▾
Current rating: 788
Peak rating: 807 (July 2023)
Gap to peak: -19
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.
Reach
20 events · us · 9.7 yrs active
2 rated weapons
▾
Tournaments: 20
Countries fought in: 1 (us)
Months active: 116
Fights / year: 12.9
Rated weapons: 2

Clubmates · Battlefield KdF● (6)

Events & fights (20)

Broken Point 2017●
March 2017 · us
No match-level data
8 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 898 ▼123 · 1,058.7
LOSS
Dave Kaufman● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1442 14%
LOSS
Juniper Losito● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword
940 45%
LOSS
Alexander Kotarakos● Longsword
1311 25%
DRAW
Brandon Shuler● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
LOSS
Chris Hobbs● · Steel City Historical Fencing● Longsword
1650 5%
LOSS
Jamie Kikilidis● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
1178 38%
LOSS
Matthew Daitsman● · Tri-State Historical Fencing Club● Longsword
LOSS
Karl Bolle● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword
1461 13%
Fechtschule New York 2016●
June 2016 · us
No match-level data
19 fights ▾
LOSS
Jayson Barrons● · Denver Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1400 39%
LOSS
Rebecca Glass● · L'Arte Della Bellica● Longsword
855 64%
LOSS
Casper Ellestad-Andersen● · Aros Historical Fencing Guild● Longsword
1542 31%
WIN
Meghan O'Connell● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
WIN
Marcus Johnson● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
742 63%
LOSS
Jim Brooks● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
1185 46%
LOSS
Jayson Barrons● · Denver Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1400 39%
WIN
Lissa Harris● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
LOSS
Stephen Cheney● · Bucks Historical Longsword● Longsword
1301 38%
LOSS
Sarah Oakhill● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
LOSS
Benjamin Strickling● · Triangle Sword Guild● Longsword
1531 31%
LOSS
Charles Murdock● · Grünberg Freifechter● Longsword
1391 40%
LOSS
Simai Liu● · Steel City Historical Fencing● Longsword
1290 38%
LOSS
Keith Lyons● · Medieval European Martial Arts Guild● Longsword
WIN
John Rothe● · Pennsylvania Klopffechters● Longsword
1204 46%
WIN
Deena Sadek● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1087 47%
WIN
Sarah Oakhill● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
LOSS
Siva Sernvongsat● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
WIN
Kenny Mai● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
Wrath Point 2016●
October 2016 · us
No match-level data
4 fights ▾
LOSS
Christy Conley● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword
929 73%
LOSS
Brian Ames● · Order of the Marshal● Longsword
1172 44%
LOSS
Dave Kaufman● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1464 24%
LOSS
Henry McLemore● · Virginia Academy of Fencing● Longsword
1160 48%
HILT - Historical Integrated Longsword Triathlon 2025●
August 2025 · us
4 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 4668 ▲20 · 984.8
WIN
Usman Abid● · Fenris Kunst Des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools Score 3-2 Review →
LOSS
Christopher Smoot● · Fenris Kunst Des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools
1436 12%
LOSS
Sean Pabers● · Mid-Atlantic Society for Historic Swordsmanship● Longsword · Pools Score 2-6 Review →
1132 32%
LOSS
Brad Purrone● · Richmond Kunst Des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools Score 0-7 Review →
1129 31%
Broken Point 2016●
February 2016 · us
No match-level data
4 fights ▾
LOSS
Pete May● · Hilt and Helm Pittsburgh Fencing Club● Longsword
WIN
Alex Meloi● · Tri-State Historical Fencing Club● Longsword
LOSS
Jake Norwood● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword
1560
LOSS
Toby Hall● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1466
Kings Cup 2023●
January 2023 · us
No match-level data
5 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1784 ▼92 · 1,032.0
LOSS
John Thomas● Longsword · Pool
LOSS
Michael Tucker● · Tuathair Academy of Swordsmanship● Longsword · Pool
1154 32%
WIN
Rune Smith● · Battlefield KdF● Longsword · Pool
LOSS
Kristopher Micozzi● · Long Island Historical Fencing Society● Longsword · Pool
1166 34%
LOSS
Ian Larson● · Blacksburg Blades● Longsword · Table of 128
1118 32%
Combat Con 2023●
July 2023 · us
4 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 1006 · 807.6
LOSS
Lucas Olson● · Wisconsin Historical Fencing Association● Sabre · Pool Set 1
1385
LOSS
Hai Zhu● · Mustang Sword Club● Sabre · Pool Set 1
LOSS
Eric Zhong● · F3 Sword Academy● Sabre · Pool Set 1
942
LOSS
Robert Placencia● · Ironwood Historic Swordsmanship● Sabre · Pool Set 1
1095
Revolution Rumble 2023●
July 2023 · us
3 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 2545 ▼185 · 1,004.3
LOSS
Harley Jelis● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · !! Attention !! Excluded From Scoring Calculations Pool Set 1 Score 0-5 Review →
1443 11%
LOSS
Geoff Ebbert● · L'Arte Della Bellica● Longsword · !! Attention !! Excluded From Scoring Calculations Pool Set 1 Score 1-5 Review →
1164 31%
LOSS
Jacob Pigeon● · Ars Gladii● Longsword · !! Attention !! Excluded From Scoring Calculations Pool Set 1 Score 0-5 Review →
1064 46%
Pennsylvania HEMA Open 2021●
August 2021 · us
3 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1426 ▲51 · 1,057.0
LOSS
Josh Furrate● · Nachreisen Historical Fencing● Longsword · Pools Score 1-5 Review →
1414 13%
WIN
John Fenz● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools Score 6-2 · 2 doubles Review →
624 61%
LOSS
Clara Elliott● · Laurel City Historical Fencing● Longsword · Pools Score 3-5 · 1 double Review →
949 43%
Washington DC HEMA OPEN 2020●
January 2020 · us
No match-level data
6 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 2151 ▼195 · 1,086.5
LOSS
Keith Cotter-Reilly● · Atlanta Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword · Pool A
1484 10%
LOSS
Henry Kenyon● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pool A
1084 51%
LOSS
Michael Woodford● · Phoenix Society of Historical Swordsmanship● Longsword · Pool A
1360 19%
LOSS
Louis Melancon● · Virginia Academy of Fencing● Longsword · Pool A
LOSS
Victor Lavenstein● · Rhode Island Fencing Academy & Club● Longsword · Pool A
1247 30%
LOSS
Gary Moreira● Longsword · Table of 16
903 47%
Mid-Continental HEMA Open 2019●
July 2019 · us
No match-level data
5 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1781 ▼96 · 1,126.0
LOSS
Philip Kuberski● · Denver Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1123 41%
LOSS
Matt Lawrence● · Denver Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1295 24%
LOSS
Garrett Baker● · Cymbrogi School of Western Martial Arts● Longsword
1597 8%
LOSS
Adam Simmons● · Phoenix Society of Historical Swordsmanship● Longsword
1397 16%
LOSS
Garrett Baker● · Cymbrogi School of Western Martial Arts● Longsword
1597 8%
Longpoint 2017●
July 2017 · us
No match-level data
4 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1013 ▼21 · 1,085.0
WIN
Caroline Zook● · Pennsylvania Klopffechters● Longsword
944 54%
LOSS
Joseph Yeager● · Metropolitan Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1203 33%
LOSS
Scott Barb● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
1555 5%
LOSS
Zachary Showalter● · Scuffletown Federfechters● Longsword
1279 22%
Clash of Claymores 2019●
April 2019 · us
7 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1628 ▲26 · 1,144.2
LOSS
Jonathan Paulino● · Philadelphia Common Fencers Guild● Longsword · Pool Set 1
1577 9%
WIN
Zachary Hollis● · Cymbrogi School of Western Martial Arts● Longsword · Pool Set 1
LOSS
J.J. Conlon● · Gem City Duelists Society● Longsword · Pool Set 2
1381 18%
LOSS
Phil Cruz● · Fenris Kunst Des Fechtens● Longsword · Pool Set 2
1045 42%
LOSS
Marty Agerton● · Men At Arms Martial Arts● Longsword · Pool Set 3
WIN
Justin Britton● · Pennsylvania Klopffechters● Longsword · Pool Set 3
1330 22%
LOSS
Austin Straub● · Bucks Historical Longsword● Longsword · Pool Set 3
1383 18%
Wrathpoint 2018●
June 2018 · us
No match-level data
2 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1304 ▼37 · 1,147.7
WIN
Kyle Crandall● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Ladder
965 64%
LOSS
Travis Mayott● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Ladder
1666 2%
Fechtschule New York 2017●
June 2017 · us
14 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 992 ▲33 · 1,084.7
LOSS
Steven Viani● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword Score 0-1 Review →
1317 20%
LOSS
Jake Norwood● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword Score 0-1 Review →
1778 1%
WIN
Jose Neves● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword Score 1-0 Review →
LOSS
Patrick McDonald● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword Score 0-1 Review →
1086 42%
WIN
Rebecca Glass● · L'Arte Della Bellica● Longsword Score 1-0 Review →
953 65%
LOSS
Paul Kartage● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword Score 0-1 Review →
1105 38%
LOSS
Jacob Kelly● · Pennsylvania Klopffechters● Longsword Score 0-1 Review →
1345 17%
LOSS
Patrick Paglen● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
LOSS
Mike Edelson● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1523 7%
LOSS
Chris Hobbs● · Steel City Historical Fencing● Longsword
1702 2%
LOSS
Tristan Zukowski● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1413 12%
LOSS
Jeremy Wolf● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
WIN
Nicolas Engst Matthews● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
WIN
Lissa Harris● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
977 54%
Rampoint 2018●
March 2018 · us
8 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1131 ▲25 · 1,149.3
DRAW
Christian O'Connell● · Tri-State Historical Fencing Club● Longsword · Pools
1288 25%
LOSS
Pete May● · Hilt and Helm Pittsburgh Fencing Club● Longsword · Pools
1330 20%
LOSS
Luis Torres● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · Pools
1493 7%
WIN
Rob Sims● · Harrisburg Longsword● Longsword · Pools
LOSS
Jay Tsulis● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · Pools
1540 5%
DRAW
Pete May● · Hilt and Helm Pittsburgh Fencing Club● Longsword · Pools
1330 20%
LOSS
Joseph Ingrao● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools
DRAW
Gabriel Moreno● · L'Arte Della Bellica● Longsword · Pools
1145 33%
Rampoint 2018●
February 2018 · us
14 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1131 ▲25 · 1,149.3
LOSS
Justin Garey● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pool Set 1
WIN
Zachary Showalter● · Scuffletown Federfechters● Longsword · Pool Set 1
1348 17%
LOSS
Travis Mayott● · Maryland Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pool Set 1
1666 2%
WIN
Andre Troche● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · Pool Set 1
820 52%
WIN
Patrick McCaffrey● · L'Arte NYC Historical Fencing● Longsword · Pool Set 1
1281 23%
LOSS
Jay Tsulis● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · Pool Set 2 - Seeded
1484 7%
LOSS
Thomas Schratwieser● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pool Set 2 - Seeded
1324 19%
LOSS
Stephen Cheney● · Bucks Historical Longsword● Longsword · Pool Set 2 - Seeded
1556 5%
WIN
Daniel Thomas● · The HEMA Club at VCU● Longsword · Pool Set 2 - Seeded
WIN
Andre Troche● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword · Pool Set 2 - Seeded
820 52%
WIN
John Durish● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Tiered
965 57%
LOSS
Lane D'Alessandro● · L'Arte Della Bellica● Longsword · Tiered
1220 26%
LOSS
Daniel Halliday● · Liberty Sword Club● Longsword · Tiered
1148 34%
LOSS
Ashleigh Hobbs● · Steel City Historical Fencing● Longsword · Tiered
1056 54%
DC HEMA Open 2018●
January 2018 · us
No match-level data
3 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 1266 ▲8 · 1,085.4
LOSS
Joseph Lilly● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools
1336 17%
LOSS
Piotr Przanowski● · Charlottesville HEMA● Longsword · Pools
1543 6%
WIN
Kyle Crandall● · Capital Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword · Pools
Capitol Clash: Washington DC HEMA Open 2017●
January 2017 · us
No match-level data
4 fights ▾
LOSS
Rick Long● · Omaha Kunst des Fechtens● Longsword
1132 37%
LOSS
Joseph Ceirante● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1365 25%
LOSS
Mckenzie Adlai Ewing● · Atlanta Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1645 7%
LOSS
Joseph Yeager● · Metropolitan Historical Fencing Academy● Longsword
1097 57%
Broken Point 2017●
April 2017 · us
No match-level data
4 fights ▾
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Longsword Rank 898 ▼123 · 1,058.7
LOSS
Toby Hall● · New York Historical Fencing Association● Longsword
1634 3%
LOSS
Frank Zamary● · Columbus United Fencing Club● Longsword
1614 6%
LOSS
Tim Lyle● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
WIN
George Faltot● · Broken Plow Western Martial Arts● Longsword
863 58%
How to read this profile

Rating is Glicko-2: the number shown is score - 2*RD (97.5% confidence lower bound), not raw skill. Inactive fighters "drift down" as RD grows - not because they got worse.

Hemaratings ratings don't factor in match scores, exchange counts, or doubles. Scout's score-margin and style metrics describe HOW a fighter fights, not the rating tier their results earned.

Hemaratings recomputes in batches days-to-weeks after events. A fighter's most recent tournament may not yet be reflected.