Skip to main content

Tom Costello

Five Rings Fencing · United States
Inactive 13m

Weapons & Rank/ratings

Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre
Current
1341 #771
Peak
1357 August 2025
Record
28W · 28L · 5D
Last
August 2025
Mixed & Men's Steel Single Rapier
Current
1112 #1,153
Peak
1154 May 2024
Record
27W · 25L · 3D
Last
May 2025
Mixed & Men's Steel Rapier and Dagger
Inactive
Current
1033
Peak
1058 May 2023
Record
27W · 25L · 3D
Last
May 2023

Scout analysis

Sabre

28W · 28L · 5D (46%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 40% vs older 50%
Record: 28W · 28L · 5D (46%)
Recent half (30 fights): 40%
Older half (30 fights): 50%
Delta: -10%
Current streak: 1 Loss
Based on 61 recorded sabre fights.
Schedule
Getting ambushed
-4 vs expectation
Quality wins (won as clear underdog): 1
Upset losses (lost as clear favourite): 4
Over/under vs expectation: -4 (11 actual / 15 expected, n=32)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Measured
7 exchange-coded matches
Exchanges per point: 0.91
Avg exchanges / match: 5.9
Doubles / match: 1.29
First scorer rate: 57%
Dominant wins (shut-out): 0%
Comeback wins (was behind): 33%
Stage
Balanced
Pool 54% · Elim 50%
Pool stage: 21W · 18L (54%)
Elimination: 6W · 6L (50%)
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
At peak
Near career best
Current rating: 1341
Peak rating: 1357 (August 2025)
Gap to peak: -15
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.

Rapier

27W · 25L · 3D (49%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 22% vs older 74%
Record: 27W · 25L · 3D (49%)
Recent half (27 fights): 22%
Older half (27 fights): 74%
Delta: -52%
Current streak: 1 Win
Based on 55 recorded rapier fights.
Schedule
Comfort bracket
-1.7 vs expectation
Over/under vs expectation: -1.7 (0 actual / 1.7 expected, n=5)
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate, comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Knockout killer
Pool 43% · Elim 75%
Pool stage: 16W · 21L (43%)
Elimination: 9W · 3L (75%)
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
42 pts off peak
Currently below peak
Current rating: 1112
Peak rating: 1154 (May 2024)
Gap to peak: -42
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.
By division
Mixed Steel Rapier And Any Sidearm 14W · 11L (56%)
Mixed Steel Single Rapier 3W · 11L · 3D (18%) -1.7 vs expectation (n=5) avg opponent 1453
Mixed Steel Rapier & Optional Dagger 8W · 0L (100%)
+5 fights in 1 thinner division

Smallsword

18W · 21L (46%)
Form
Cooling
Recent 32% vs older 58%
Record: 18W · 21L (46%)
Recent half (19 fights): 32%
Older half (19 fights): 58%
Delta: -26%
Current streak: 5 Losses
Based on 39 recorded smallsword fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate, comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Balanced
Pool 46% · Elim 56%
Pool stage: 13W · 15L (46%)
Elimination: 5W · 4L (56%)
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.

Rapier & Dagger

2W · 3L · 3D (25%)
Form
Rising
Recent 50% vs older 0%
Record: 2W · 3L · 3D (25%)
Recent half (4 fights): 50%
Older half (4 fights): 0%
Delta: +50%
Current streak: 1 Win
Based on 8 recorded rapier & dagger fights.
Schedule
Schedule forming
Expectation data pending
Over/under needs 5+ rated fights - calculating as more data lands.
Expectation stats compare each result with the win chance implied by both fighters' ratings in that division.
Style
Building signal
Needs more exchange data
Style signal needs per-exchange match data. Once enough of this fighter's exchanges are recorded, this card will sharpen into scoring tempo, doubles rate, comeback wins, early vs late scoring, and more.
Stage
Pool data only
Pool 50%
Pool stage: 2W · 2L (50%)
Elimination: needs 3+ coded fights.
Stage tagging depends on upstream division labels - some fights may be uncategorised.
Peak
Peak data pending
Peak volatility low
Peak rating comes from the highest Glicko value recorded for this weapon.
Reach
10 events · us · 7 yrs active
2 rated weapons
Tournaments: 10
Countries fought in: 1 (us)
Months active: 84
Fights / year: 23.3
Rated weapons: 2

Clubmates · Five Rings Fencing (12)

Events & fights (11)

Donnybrook 2025
August 2025 · us
13 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 558 ▲2 · 1,357.7
LOSS
Thomas Amoroso · Columbus Saber Academy Sabre · Pools Score 8-10 · 1 double Review →
1427 40%
WIN
824 80%
WIN
1267 60%
LOSS
Court Dyke · Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy Sabre · Top 8 Score 0-12 · 2 doubles Review →
1503 28%
WIN
Ash Tyr · Columbus Saber Academy Rapier · Pools Score 9-8 Review →
LOSS
LOSS
Natalie Johanek · Arena Weapon Arts Rapier · Pools Score 3-10 Review →
LOSS
Beau Hulgan · Arena Weapon Arts Rapier · Top 32 Score 3-13 Review →
WIN
LOSS
LOSS
Ralph Hill · Omaha Kunst des Fechtens Smallsword · Pools Score 7-9 Review →
LOSS
Sage Nagai · Noble Science Academy Smallsword · Pools Score 0-9 Review →
LOSS
SwordStrong 2025
May 2025 · us
17 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 537 ▲32 · 1,356.4
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Single Rapier Rank 909 ▼98 · 1,125.8
WIN
1274 55%
DRAW
Eric Denney · Medieval Military Arts Academy Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 1-1 Review →
1233 55%
LOSS
Chandler Brown · En Garde Fencing Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 0-3 Review →
1641 18%
WIN
1041 59%
DRAW
1516 26%
LOSS
1626 18%
LOSS
1087 58%
LOSS
Gavin Page · Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy Sabre · Top 16 Score 0-3 Review →
1735 13%
LOSS
1487 35%
LOSS
Thomas Nicol · Tempered Mettle Historical Fencing Rapier · Pool Set 1 Score 1-3 Review →
1424 35%
LOSS
1404 40%
LOSS
William Fischer · Omaha-Metro Armed Combat Academy Rapier · Pool Set 1 Score 0-3 · 2 doubles Review →
WIN
Craig Hosey · Guild of Knightly Arts Rapier · Pool Set 2
LOSS
1310 42%
LOSS
Gavin Page · Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy Rapier · Pool Set 2 Score 0-3 Review →
1736 18%
Donnybrook 2024
August 2024 · us
15 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 422 ▲38 · 1,334.5
LOSS
Thomas Amoroso · Columbus Saber Academy Sabre · Gold Medal Match Score 7-9 · 1 double Review →
1429 40%
WIN
Lisa McGuire · Baerswords School of Western Martial Arts Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 11-1 · 1 double Review →
677 83%
WIN
James Glackin · Heartland HEMA Historical Fencing Club Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 6-5 · 1 double Review →
1297 56%
LOSS
Thomas Amoroso · Columbus Saber Academy Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 7-9 · 1 double Review →
1429 40%
LOSS
Tyler Larson · Omaha-Metro Armed Combat Academy Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 6-9 · 1 double Review →
997 78%
WIN
James Glackin · Heartland HEMA Historical Fencing Club Sabre · Quarterfinals Score 6-5 · 1 double Review →
1297 56%
WIN
LOSS
Torin Dabbs · Burning Sun Historical Swordsmanship Rapier · Elimination Bracket Score 8-9 Review →
LOSS
Paul Hubbard · House of Blades Rapier · Pool Set 1 Score 8-10 Review →
WIN
LOSS
Gavin Page · Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy Rapier · Pool Set 1 Score 3-9 Review →
LOSS
Michael Waggoner · Omaha Kunst des Fechtens Smallsword · Elimination Bracket
LOSS
Ryan Leonard · Hilt and Helm Pittsburgh Fencing Club Smallsword · Pool Set 1 Score 10-11 Review →
WIN
Eric Denney · Medieval Military Arts Academy Smallsword · Pool Set 1 Score 10-2 Review →
LOSS
Lucas Olson · Wisconsin Historical Fencing Association Smallsword · Pool Set 1 Score 7-11 Review →
SwordStrong KC 2024
May 2024 · us
9 fights
WIN
1156
LOSS
Paul Hubbard · House of Blades Rapier · Pool Set 1
1523
LOSS
Robert Childs · Black Tigers Rapier · Pool Set 2
2007
LOSS
Clare Lahey · SoCal Swords Rapier · Pool Set 2
1023
LOSS
WIN
Nico Schreck · House of Blades Rapier · Pool Set 2
DRAW
1446
Donnybrook 2023
August 2023 · us
4 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 266 ▼13 · 1,336.8
LOSS
LOSS
Trent Burg · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 1-11 Review →
1202 55%
WIN
Court Dyke · Wichita Fencing & HEMA Academy Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 7-4 · 2 doubles Review →
1485 29%
LOSS
SwordStrong KC 2023
May 2023 · us
18 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 228 ▲113 · 1,349.0
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Rapier and Dagger Rank 321 · 1,058.1
LOSS
Jeremy Pace · Cymbrogi School of Western Martial Arts Rapier & Dagger · Eighth-Finals
LOSS
DRAW
Matt Karmelich · House of Blades Rapier & Dagger · Pool Set 1
DRAW
Spencer Gard · House of Blades Rapier & Dagger · Pool Set 1
DRAW
WIN
Robert Illston · Guild of Knightly Arts Rapier & Dagger · Pool Set 2
LOSS
Zachary Boyd · Second Intent Fencing Rapier & Dagger · Pool Set 2
828
WIN
Matt Karmelich · House of Blades Rapier & Dagger · Pool Set 2
WIN
Scott Hansen · House of Blades Sabre · Eighth-Finals Score 3-1 Review →
1248 43%
DRAW
1316 47%
WIN
Mac Siruta · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 1
1019 63%
WIN
Syrus Chang · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 3-2 Review →
WIN
Gavin Burg · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 1 Score 5-0 Review →
WIN
Syrus Chang · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 2 Score 3-2 Review →
LOSS
988 71%
WIN
Gavin Burg · House of Blades Sabre · Pool Set 2 Score 5-0 Review →
LOSS
Joshua Dale · Union Historical Fencing Sabre · Quarterfinals Score 0-4 Review →
1362 40%
Donnybrook 2022
June 2022 · us
13 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 185 ▲16 · 1,261.9
LOSS
Joseph Thibodaux · Albuquerque Sword Labs Sabre · Bronze Medal Match
WIN
WIN
Micha Rieser · Athena School of Arms Sabre · Pool Set 1
LOSS
WIN
Robert Illston · Guild of Knightly Arts Sabre · Quarterfinals
LOSS
WIN
WIN
Zachary Boyd · Second Intent Fencing Rapier · Pool Set 1
LOSS
LOSS
Matt Karmelich · House of Blades Smallsword · Pool Set 1
LOSS
LOSS
Joseph Thibodaux · Albuquerque Sword Labs Smallsword · Pool Set 1
24 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 314 ▲28 · 1,230.3
LOSS
1730 15%
LOSS
882 70%
LOSS
1730 15%
WIN
WIN
WIN
WIN
WIN
LOSS
Zachary Boyd · Second Intent Fencing Smallsword · Pool 2
WIN
LOSS
Five Rings Classical Fencing Open 2019
September 2019 · us
No match-level data
12 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 389 ▲30 · 1,196.1
Five Rings Fencing Annual KC Sword Tournament 2018
September 2018 · us
No match-level data
24 fights
Rating outcome
  • Mixed & Men's Steel Sabre Rank 293 · 1,174.8
LOSS
WIN
LOSS
Mark Pickerell · Second Intent Fencing Sabre · Quarter Finals
LOSS
Steve Oler · Five Rings Fencing Rapier · Pool 2
WIN
WIN
Timothy Maurer · Second Intent Fencing Rapier · Quarter Finals
LOSS
Matt Torres · Five Rings Fencing Rapier · Semi Finals
LOSS
Brea Black · Five Rings Fencing Smallsword · Eliminations
LOSS
Matt Torres · Five Rings Fencing Smallsword · Pool 2
WIN
LOSS
Summer Swordfest 2019
June 2019
No match-level data
14 fights
How to read this profile

Rating is Glicko-2: the number shown is score - 2*RD (97.5% confidence lower bound), not raw skill. Inactive fighters "drift down" as RD grows - not because they got worse.

Hemaratings ratings don't factor in match scores, exchange counts, or doubles. Scout's score-margin and style metrics describe HOW a fighter fights, not the rating tier their results earned.

Hemaratings recomputes in batches days-to-weeks after events. A fighter's most recent tournament may not yet be reflected.